The Top 10 Most Misunderstood Baking Ingredients—and What They Really Do

Some baking ingredients have a PR problem. Whether it’s a confusing name, a scary-sounding label, or a reputation built on myths, these staples are often misjudged. But in the hands of a baker, they're powerful tools. Here’s what you really need to know about ten of the most misunderstood ingredients in the industry—and why they deserve a place in your kitchen.

The Myth:
It’s synthetic, allergenic, and unnecessary.

The Truth:
Lecithin is a naturally occurring phospholipid, not a lab-made additive. It’s extracted from sources like soy, sunflower, and rapeseed—and while soy lecithin is most common, it's typically processed in a way that removes almost all allergenic proteins. Functionally, lecithin is a multitasker: it emulsifies, stabilizes, and extends shelf life. It’s also a go-to for improving dough flow and texture in industrial baking.

Why It’s Essential in Baking or Cooking:
Lecithin is a backbone emulsifier that brings cohesion to otherwise unstable mixtures. In baking, it’s prized for improving dough elasticity, helping baked goods rise evenly and hold their structure longer. It reduces sticking during processing and enhances moisture retention—so breads and pastries stay softer and fresher on shelves. In cooking, it stabilizes creamy sauces, vinaigrettes, and foams. If you've ever had a velvety hollandaise or a glossy chocolate glaze, lecithin probably had something to do with it.

The Myth:
It’s just another “chemical” with no real purpose.

The Truth:
DATEM (diacetyl tartaric acid esters of mono- and diglycerides) sounds intimidating, but it’s simply an emulsifier made from edible oils and organic acids. It strengthens gluten, improves crumb structure, and enhances the volume of bread. It’s especially useful in commercial bread production, helping loaves rise higher and hold their shape. While some studies suggest further research on high-dose effects, it’s considered safe by FDA and EFSA standards.

Why It’s Essential in Baking:
DATEM boosts gas retention and improves oven spring—two major keys to great bread. It strengthens the gluten network, creating better dough stability and finer crumb structure. This is especially helpful in lean doughs or large-scale production settings where consistent performance is critical. Whether you're making sandwich loaves or dinner rolls, DATEM helps deliver volume, softness, and uniformity.

The Myth:
It’s a dairy product—or something to do with tartar sauce.

The Truth:
Cream of tartar (potassium bitartrate) is a byproduct of winemaking and a mild acid, not a creamy sauce or dairy derivative. It stabilizes whipped egg whites, prevents sugar from crystallizing in syrups and candies, and when paired with baking soda, works as a leavening agent. Without it, your meringue would flop, and your snickerdoodles wouldn’t have that iconic chewy texture.

Why It’s Essential in Baking:
Cream of tartar is the secret to light, airy bakes. It keeps whipped egg whites from collapsing, making it a staple in meringues, angel food cakes, and soufflés. It also controls sugar crystallization in candies and frostings, keeping textures smooth. Paired with baking soda, it creates a natural leavening system that’s ideal for cookies and some cakes. No cream of tartar? Say goodbye to glossy peaks and chewy textures.

The Myth:
It’s only for gym bros and bodybuilders.

The Truth:
Whey protein concentrate is a functional ingredient that supports protein fortification and can improve browning, softness, and nutritional profile in baked goods. It’s a complete protein that works well in bars, muffins, and even pancakes. Concerns about kidney damage are typically only relevant for people with pre-existing conditions, and it's well tolerated by many, even those with mild lactose sensitivity.

Why It’s Essential in Baking or Cooking:
Whey protein brings more to the table than muscle. In baking, it supports structure and moisture retention while boosting nutritional value. It enhances browning and improves the chew in products like protein bars, cookies, and muffins. In cooking, it blends easily into sauces, smoothies, and soups for a low-effort protein boost. It's versatile, cost-effective, and clean-tasting—ideal for both sweet and savory formats.

The Myth:
It’s just a thickener—or worse, a digestive nightmare.

The Truth:
Xanthan gum is far more than a cornstarch replacement. In gluten-free baking, it acts as a binder, holding together crumbly doughs that lack gluten. Yes, large doses may cause bloating, but in the tiny amounts used in baking, it’s perfectly safe. Made via fermentation, xanthan gum plays a crucial role in improving texture, moisture retention, and elasticity in doughs and batters

Why It’s Essential in Baking:
For gluten-free bakers, xanthan gum is what holds everything together. It creates the structure that gluten typically provides, making it essential for keeping bread from falling apart or cookies from crumbling. It also improves elasticity, so doughs stretch and rise properly. In sauces or frostings, it keeps everything smooth and stable. It’s tiny but mighty—just a little bit goes a long way.

The Myth:
It’s synthetic, unhealthy, and unnecessary.

The Truth:
SSL is made from naturally occurring stearic and lactic acids and is used to improve softness and shelf life in baked goods. It enhances gas retention, helps create fine, uniform crumbs, and extends the freshness of bread products. Some studies suggest it may influence gut bacteria in large amounts, but in normal usage levels, it's a workhorse for commercial bakeries—not a red flag.

Why It’s Essential in Baking:
SSL is your insurance policy against tough or dry bread. It strengthens dough during mixing and fermentation, boosts loaf volume, and maintains softness over time. It also helps create that desirable fine crumb structure that gives sandwich breads their signature feel. For commercial bakers, it’s a consistent, reliable tool for texture and shelf life.

The Myth:
It’s just vitamin C, and it doesn't belong in bread.

The Truth:
While ascorbic acid is vitamin C, it also serves as a dough conditioner in baking. It helps strengthen gluten and improve gas retention, leading to better rise and structure—especially in lean doughs. It’s not about health halos here; it’s about function. And no, it doesn’t make your bread taste like oranges.

Why It’s Essential in Baking:
Ascorbic acid strengthens the gluten matrix, helping dough trap more gas and rise higher. It’s especially useful in lean breads with few fats or sugars. It also contributes to better crust formation and a more open crumb. Whether you’re working with French baguettes or sandwich loaves, ascorbic acid gives your dough the backbone it needs to perform consistently.

The Myth:
They’re mysterious and probably overkill.

The Truth:
Enzymes are naturally occurring proteins that speed up specific chemical reactions. In baking, they help break down starches, proteins, or fats to improve fermentation, dough stability, and shelf life. They're often wrongly labeled as unnecessary additives when, in reality, they help create consistent, high-quality results—especially in large-scale production.

Why It’s Essential in Baking:
Each enzyme serves a unique purpose. Amylase breaks down starch into sugars, feeding yeast and enhancing browning. Protease softens dough and improves extensibility. Lipase contributes to flavor by interacting with fats. Used together or alone, enzymes help fine-tune dough behavior, fermentation time, and texture, particularly in large-scale production where consistency is key.

The Myth:
They’re always animal-based and unhealthy.

The Truth:
Mono- and diglycerides are emulsifiers derived from fats—often vegetable oils. They help water and oil stay blended, which is essential for soft textures and preventing staling in baked goods. Though associated with processed foods, they play a legitimate functional role and can be sourced vegan. They're also naturally present in small amounts in many edible fats.

Why It’s Essential in Baking or Cooking:
These emulsifiers make baked goods softer, moister, and longer-lasting. In breads, they extend shelf life by keeping fats evenly distributed. In cakes, they improve volume and crumb. In cooking, they stabilize emulsions in sauces, ice creams, and margarine. They may not sound glamorous, but without them, your loaf would dry out fast—and your frosting could split.

The Myth:
It’s a harsh preservative with scary side effects.

The Truth:
Sorbic acid is a mold and yeast inhibitor used to prevent spoilage in baked goods, cheeses, and fruit products. It’s often misunderstood as a synthetic danger, but it’s originally derived from mountain ash berries and is considered safe by the FDA. Reactions are rare and usually limited to skin contact in cosmetics—not from food. Without it, shelf-stable baked goods would spoil far faster.

Why It’s Essential in Baking or Cooking:
Sorbic acid acts as a silent shield in foods that need to sit on a shelf. It prevents spoilage without changing taste, texture, or color. That’s why it’s common in muffins, tortillas, snack cakes, and even fruit fillings. It extends freshness and reduces waste—two big wins in both wholesale baking and food manufacturing.

These ingredients may not win any popularity contests, but they play critical roles in modern baking. Whether it’s strengthening dough, extending shelf life, or improving texture, each misunderstood additive has a job—and most are backed by decades of science, regulation, and use in commercial kitchens.

At Baker’s Authority, we don’t just stock ingredients—we help you understand them. Whether you’re scaling production, improving shelf life, or experimenting with clean-label formulations, we’re here to make sure the ingredients you use work for you—not against you.

Need bulk emulsifiers, dough conditioners, or functional proteins?
We’ve got your back.